Ground Stops and Cleanup Rounds – Episode 34 of Unbuffered

Unbuffered Logo - Two text bubbles

In this episode of Unbuffered, Chris is joined again by Sean Gonsalves for a candid conversation on three federal agencies making headlines: the FAA, the FCC, and NTIA.

Together, they start with the nationwide FAA ground stop, which reportedly stemmed from a misconfigured router during a copper-to-fiber upgrade. Sean questions Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy’s call for $50 billion in new funding, noting the billions already allocated for FAA facilities and air traffic control in the infrastructure law and other legislation. 

Chris explains how a single router misconfiguration can cascade across a network, recalling the time a Pakistani network accidentally took YouTube offline worldwide, and argues that decisions like this should be made by experts. They also discuss a recent string of major outages, AI-driven security patches, and the loss of federal cybersecurity expertise after DOGE cuts.

Moving to the FCC, they cover the push to pair the confirmation of Chairman Carr’s nominee with Democratic Commissioner Gomez, so the commission isn’t left without minority representation. They discuss a new letter urging Senators Cruz and Cantwell to keep the pairing, credit Senator Cruz for speaking out against efforts to chill broadcast speech, and consider whether Congress should change the law to require minority representation on the commission.

Concluding with BEAD, Sean highlights Chris’s new op-ed calling on Congress to direct NTIA to send all remaining BEAD funds to the states, including roughly $20 billion in non-deployment funds. 

Chris argues that state broadband offices are now ready to make these decisions, points to the American Rescue Plan as proof that sending money to states works, and makes the case that states should be allowed to use funds for affordability programs.

The episode wraps with a quick look at SpaceX’s latest Starship flight and the launch failure that set back Amazon Leo.

This show is 36 minutes long and can be played on this page or via Apple Podcasts or the tool of your choice using this feed. 

You can also check out the video version via YouTube.

Transcript below.

We want your feedback and suggestions for the show-please e-mail us or leave a comment below.

Listen to other episodes in our index. See other podcasts from the Institute for Local Self-Reliance.

Thanks to Whitedrift for the song Operator, licensed Creative Commons Attribution (3.0).

Podcast Audio Embed
Transcript

Christopher Mitchell (00:16)
This is Unbuffered, a show in which we're going to share our Unbuffered takes on a few issues around the FCC, the FAA, and giving a F to the NTIA department.

Sean Gonsalves (00:30)
Right.

Christopher Mitchell (00:31)
So this is the Unbuffered show coming to you from the Institute for Local Self Reliance. I'm Chris Mitchell. I run the Community Broadband Networks Initiative. news on that coming up in a few weeks.

with me though is Sean Gonsalves who runs our communications, does a lot of writing and thinking. Welcome, Sean.

Sean Gonsalves (00:50)
All right. I am ready to be Unbuffered and I'm not in the air.

Christopher Mitchell (00:55)
All right, so we're gonna I think I I'm I'm gonna I'm gonna share this with you now because it's too late for you to back out. But I think

Sean Gonsalves (01:00)
Okay. Okay.

Christopher Mitchell (01:02)
you're gonna be a little bit we're gonna talk a little bit about the FAA and this ground stop, and you're

Sean Gonsalves (01:05)
Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.

Christopher Mitchell (01:07)
gonna be a little bit conspiratorial. And I'm gonna try and break that bubble. but also

Sean Gonsalves (01:09)
Yeah. Please, yes, yes.

Christopher Mitchell (01:12)
I'll just say that like I was last week in Alaska,

Sean Gonsalves (01:15)
Right.

Christopher Mitchell (01:16)
near Naknek for the in Bristol Bay for a tribal broadband camp.

I and several others took the red eyes out of Anchorage in order to get home a little bit faster.

Sean Gonsalves (01:26)
Just in time.

Christopher Mitchell (01:27)
The people who didn't, they got stuck. they got stuck in Seattle, they got stuck, they landed at JFK for Esther and Cody, and then they were unable to get off the plane because all the gates were taken up by planes that were not allowed to take off. So kind of miserable. And we're gonna talk a little bit about what happened there, but I think, you know, we don't we don't fully know yet.

So there's some larger principles we want to talk about. So why don't you kick it off?

Sean Gonsalves (01:54)
Right. So I mean everybody that's listening to this knows all about the ground stop and and all the headache and stuff that that covered.

Christopher Mitchell (02:00)
Right, because they're very

well informed by the the person running Homeland Security, Markwayne Mullen and Secretary Duffy, famous for being on a television, reality television show. Yeah,

Sean Gonsalves (02:11)
The real world. Mm-hmm.

Christopher Mitchell (02:12)
the real world. No, it was was it Road Rules? Was it real world? It was on MTV. Yeah.

Sean Gonsalves (02:15)
I think it might have been the real world. I don't know. Some MTV. Yeah. Yeah.

Christopher Mitchell (02:20)
And yeah, this they made it I feel like their mission was to convince people that that we should have experts in charge of things and not randos.

and they they proved that to me. I'm convinced.

Sean Gonsalves (02:32)
Yeah.

Yeah, I mean, you know, you I you probably saw like all of the the dumb and dumber like memes and stuff. I mean that that that press conference was was you know to call it a circus is being real nice. I you there's all kinds of swearing that you could do to like to describe it, but I mean

Christopher Mitchell (02:47)
It's insulting.

Sean Gonsalves (02:48)
it it it it it's insulting and and like you said, nobody really knows. I mean they talked about like this this conversion from copper lines to fiber, which is something that, you know, we we're very much you know

look at and talk about all the time. And then they're talking about this this router that that that went bad or or and and then this the software update and everything. And just for me, again, not being an engineer, I don't really know much about routers, but it just seems like improbable that a single router is the reason why all these planes were grounded. But that's not even like we don't really like need to get into the technical stuff about, you know,

Well, first of all, the importance of fiber and updating and and in and networks and all of that kind of stuff. And the idea that also that they don't have redundant systems is ridiculous because they do. But the point that it raised to me is because there's all this reporting, and then of course Sean Duffy goes out, and first he said, I think like a week ago, that, you know, we need 30 billion dollars from the FCC to, you know, to to do these upgrades. And then at this press conference, he talks about how they need

50 billion. And so I'm saying to myself two things. First of all, when you're designing network upgrades or anything like that, you can't just like snap your fingers or just look around the room and be like and come up with an estimate of 50 billion. And then the other thing is, is like, because we covered this so much, there was this thing called the infrastructure law. And in it, besides there being all this money for broadband and building new networks, there was

$5 billion for FAA facilities, another 20 billion for airports and airport upgrades. And so, and then I think in the big beautiful bill or whatever they call that thing, there was another 12.5 billion for for air traffic control. So, so when he's asking for this money, and I'm seeing reporting without that context, the question is, where did that money go?

Christopher Mitchell (04:45)
So let me interrupt you for a second, because I think it's worth understanding what was happening there at a at a political level. But also let's start back at the beginning a little bit to make sure that I mean a lot of folks that are on this show, they're probably already familiar with what you mean by copper to fiber upgrades. But like, you know, it's worth noting that like a lot of telecommunications used to be conducted over copper, literally conducted, right? I mean, that's why they use copper.

Sean Gonsalves (05:09)
Mm-hmm.

Christopher Mitchell (05:09)
And

And like we used to build stuff to last, right? And so like like the old telephones that like, you know, that AT&T leased to people for decades, built by Western Tel or whatever, I forget who it was. you know, you could you could club someone with that and it's still gonna work if you know for another fifty years. Like it was built solid. And so we are upgrading from copper to fiber, and there's good reasons to be doing that, and it'll probably re increase reliability.

And so we're moving from like technologies that were using copper to technologies that are digital using fiber optics. And there's a lot of good reasons to do that. And as as part of these upgrades, there was a router. And apparently a router had some configuration issue in which it was flooding the network in some way. And my understanding was that they took everything else offline because they were not because there was a necessarily an issue, but because they didn't know if it would happen elsewhere too.

And they wanted to make sure that they were safe with whatever they were doing to make sure that this issue that was happening wouldn't suddenly start happening everywhere. And so when it comes to federal air travel, I think we probably want to err on the safe side, right? now the

Sean Gonsalves (06:19)
Mm-hmm. I know I mm hmm.

Christopher Mitchell (06:21)
thing that but the thing that I that's sort of like that's those are some facts as best I understand. One of the interpretations that I come to though is that like we should have experts making this decision. In no way do I think the call was made by an expert.

To shut down the air travel. I think it was made by someone who is like, I don't be responsible. I don't even know. I don't understand how any this stuff works. I don't so shut it all down, you know? Like, and then and then when he goes on television, Secretary Duffy goes on television, you should interpret everything he says as President Trump, I'd like to keep my job. President Trump, I'd like to keep my job. President Trump, I should

Sean Gonsalves (06:52)
Right, right, for sure.

Christopher Mitchell (06:53)
like to keep my job. President Trump, I'd like to keep my job. And so the only way you do that is by is by going on the attack mode and never admitting that you did anything wrong, never admitting any uncertainty. And so

That's what's happening here. It's not that Secretary Duffy thinks that's the best thing to do. I don't think he just wanted to keep his job. And so he got on television because that's what President Trump demands. And this is the system that we have. And he's responding to those incentives. So, like, none of the words that he said out of the hole in his head, like to me, matter because the whole point of that was just President Trump, I'd like to keep my job. And I think it's worth

Sean Gonsalves (07:26)
I mean

Christopher Mitchell (07:27)
understanding that. Like any anything we're gonna learn about this is not gonna come from him, not on television, certainly.

Sean Gonsalves (07:32)
True, except that him and others are still parroting what he said, which is this sort of th this was the crazy part to me is he was b he basically almost said verbatim, but it was like implying that it won't be safe to fly until you give us like fifty billion more dollars. And and it kind of felt it it feels it feels like you we're we're part of like this ransomware attack by the own by by the government. Like it's crazy that you know that you

Christopher Mitchell (07:55)
Right. Also, like,

like I don't know how that works because you get 50 billion dollars. You don't spend it overnight, right? Like it takes a few minutes to get through the system. So yeah, I mean, like we have air travel in the meantime. But I do I'll I'll take I'll take issue with something you said though. Like the thing that I really

Sean Gonsalves (08:03)
Right, right. But Okay.

Christopher Mitchell (08:09)
want to take from a networking point of view.

Sean Gonsalves (08:11)
Mm-hmm.

Christopher Mitchell (08:12)
I do you remember? I mean, this was I was trying to remember where I was because I was I was at at the Institute for Local Self Reliance, only a few years in is probably like 2011, maybe even 2010, something like that.

Sean Gonsalves (08:23)
Okay.

Christopher Mitchell (08:23)
And

YouTube went down across the

Sean Gonsalves (08:25)
Mm-hmm.

Christopher Mitchell (08:25)
whole world. And it later turned out that on the the border gateway protocol, the the way that routers work is they do this thing called advertising routes. And it's basically like you think of it like a machine that's like I want to send this packet of information to this destination. How do I get there? And like this advertising

Sean Gonsalves (08:43)
Mm. Mm-hmm.

Christopher Mitchell (08:45)
of routes is what allows routers to talk to each other and to make and to route the information literally from computer to computer.

Get to its destination and some

Sean Gonsalves (08:54)
Okay.

Christopher Mitchell (08:55)
misconfiguration in the the it's called zone file. I believe. I mean, some of this is this is not anywhere near my core of competence, but like every time I have to touch a zone file, which I do every now and then, I'm just sweating bullets. because if you put a comma or a period in the wrong spot, like good lord, you could shut down YouTube. And so this,

Sean Gonsalves (09:12)
Mm. Mm. Mm-hmm.

Christopher Mitchell (09:15)
like, Pakistan, this this network in Pakistan misconfigured their zone file, and like for some reason they started advertising, like, we have all the YouTube videos.

Come to us for all of the YouTube videos. And so the whole world started being like, Where are those YouTube videos? And they were like, We are not able to respond to this volume of traffic. I mean, it was just like, you know, you can imagine if like if the entire world started sending you every second like two letters, you know, like you're like you're like this

Sean Gonsalves (09:39)
Right, right. Yep.

Christopher Mitchell (09:41)
line of postmen around the block, like waiting to get to

Sean Gonsalves (09:43)
Ha ha ha.

Christopher Mitchell (09:44)
you. You're like, my God, I can't do anything. Well, that's what happens with networks too. So, like, I don't know. That just it reminded me of that and like your skepticism.

Like, I don't know. I some of the people on the signal that I'm in touch with were like, this is obviously a cover up. And I was like, I don't know, it seems right to me. Like, you know, one router misconfigured, boom. Like I could see it.

Sean Gonsalves (10:00)
Yeah, I mean maybe, but

yeah, yeah. But what what what's also a mystery though is as I said, this call for money for these upgrades, when there's been all of this money that's been allocated, I don't know this for for sure for for sure, but it feels to me like like with BEAD, and we're gonna talk a little bit about that later, with like some of the money being not disp dispersed, we it w you know, more people could know about it because it's involved all of the states and whether or not they're gonna get their portion of the money and everything.

But there's to me a real question around what happened to that money that was allocated and was it ever dispersed or was it like clawed back and nobody really knew about it or said anything? Because certainly money had been allocated to do some of these things. And so it just has a real question. And then and then all of this to me, and then we can move on, I think, which is that but is that there seems to be all of this weird like networky stuff going on. I mean, you had the for right the Microsoft 365 outage that happened right before the thing, you you know, chase.

Christopher Mitchell (10:58)
I'm calling it Microsoft

three sixty four.

Sean Gonsalves (11:00)
the three Microsoft three sixty four, right. Chase Bank, Bank Bank of America, Wells Fargo, they all had had issues. People couldn't get their money. I I Apple Apple,

Christopher Mitchell (11:07)
I'm with you. It's so suspicious.

Sean Gonsalves (11:10)
Gmail, even today I heard that NSA net w was having issues. Equinor, the oil and gas company, and I think even Charles Schwab, like all this stuff is going on and then I saw an alert that the

Just looking at it now that the FBI put out this flash advisory warning that cyber criminals and state-aligned hackers are exploiting ARTEX, a superintelligence-powered penetration testing framework, yada, yada, yada. anyway, it just all this going on in this atmosphere and and at a time when you've got Markwayne Mullin and and Chris Duffy out talking about technology and these other folks that who just just seem way out of their depth and and this stuff being way over their head.

is is super concerning. And then we all remember DOGE gutted so much of the of of of the federal government, cybersecurity professionals, all this kind of stuff. And it's just it I don't know.

Christopher Mitchell (12:03)
Yeah, no, I mean,

like, let's go back, right? I mean, that's that's just it. And so it's not just a matter of like they shut down agencies that shouldn't have been shut down. They shut down stuff they didn't know what they were doing. They fired everyone who is a probationary employee, which means that if you had been promoted in the last like six months or a year and you were really good at your job, you were technically a probationary employee because you'd just been promoted and you got you got kicked out. Like there's no there's no way to do anything. No one manages a company like this. and so

There's these people are incompetent. They are liars. They've lied about everything constantly. And and so, you know, I I don't know what to think, but I agree with you. All of these different things happening. Now, it's worth noting there's a couple of things that are tied up in that, right? One is we are at war with Iran. Iran engages in cyber attacks, right? not to say they do it alone. Lots of other people do it, lots of other compan countries do it too. and so like there's some of that going on behind the scenes and like the government

doesn't often want to admit if that's what's happening. I mean, we're only now starting to get the extent of what Iran actually did to our military bases in the Middle East because again, the United States government has been lying to us about all this

Sean Gonsalves (13:08)
Mm-hmm.

Christopher Mitchell (13:09)
stuff. you got North Korea just pulled off the greatest heist of all time, I think, you know. you've got these the the AI driven attacks are are also in parallel with, and I think this is what caused the the Microsoft issue.

Is that there's an unprecedented number of patches to fix security vulnerabilities that AI run by software companies is finding internally. So they're pushing out changes to their software at an unprecedented rate, which then can result in legitimate problems because it's not been properly tested. So there's just there's a lot of stuff going on. And it wouldn't surprise me in the future if some of this was not what they claimed. But

Sean Gonsalves (13:50)
Right.

Christopher Mitchell (13:51)
if you on any one given thing, I'm

Sean Gonsalves (13:53)
Mm-hmm.

Christopher Mitchell (13:54)
tempted to take the explanation that like it's like not a nefarious attack. but it's it's it's crazy times. I I certainly agree with that.

Sean Gonsalves (14:01)
It's c it's

Christopher Mitchell (14:01)
But like these people are liars and we cannot trust them.

Sean Gonsalves (14:04)
Right. And which may be part of the point, you know, to sort of r ruin like trust in in in agencies that we rely on or that we need to to to work well. So it

Christopher Mitchell (14:12)
Right. All right. So we're gonna

talk about the Federal Communications Commission, where

Sean Gonsalves (14:15)
Yes.

Christopher Mitchell (14:16)
we're not dealing with people that lie all the time.

Sean Gonsalves (14:19)
Right.

Christopher Mitchell (14:23)
the the thing is, we're we're supporting an effort. you we've we had before Berin Szoka and and Gigi Sohn came on to talk about this unprecedented campaign from FCC Chairman Carr.

The Federal Communications Commission. And I I will say that, like, whenever I see the word unprecedented, I like to do a little half step and be like, wait, is it really unprecedented? Yes,

Sean Gonsalves (14:45)
Right, exactly.

Christopher Mitchell (14:46)
it's freaking unprecedented. Like we've had Nixon attempt to to use the federal government, you know, and and what he did is pales in comparison to what

Sean Gonsalves (14:56)
Mm-hmm.

Christopher Mitchell (14:57)
I mean, not everything that he did, but the federal communications stuff like is way worse right now in terms of the efforts to chill speech that the president doesn't

Sean Gonsalves (15:04)
Right.

Christopher Mitchell (15:04)
like.

Or that Chairman Carr thinks the president might not like, to be more accurate in some cases, I think.

Sean Gonsalves (15:08)
Right. Right, exactly.

Christopher Mitchell (15:11)
so what's happening right now is that the FCC has one sorry, it has the chairman who's a Republican, Chairman Carr. It has Republican member and a Democratic member, and there needs to have three members to function by law.

And the Democrat Gomez, she is technically her term is expired, so she can continue, but she could basically be kicked off at any point by the chair, I believe. And so the concern

Sean Gonsalves (15:43)
Mm-hmm.

Christopher Mitchell (15:44)
is that the Senate may confirm Danielle Severs as the commissioner. This is a person who is a counsel to Chairman Carr. And at that point they would kick Gomez out and have just three Republicans and be able to do whatever they wanted without even having a minority vote.

of dissent or the ability to dissent on it. And it's deeply concerning. It's not the way the Federal Communications Commission should work. And so,

Sean Gonsalves (16:10)
Mm-hmm.

Christopher Mitchell (16:11)
you know, we're supportive of efforts to pair Gomez with

Sean Gonsalves (16:15)
Right.

Christopher Mitchell (16:15)
Severs. Now, Republican the Republicans, specifically Donald Trump could literally, President Trump could fire Gomez from the FCC by the logic that the Supreme Court has offered in the decisions. And

Sean Gonsalves (16:28)
Right. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.

Christopher Mitchell (16:30)
so

It's not anything that will stop it necessarily, but Congress could at least not be party to this farce of creating a commission that is supposed to be split, not totally

Sean Gonsalves (16:41)
Mm-hmm.

Christopher Mitchell (16:42)
evenly, but supposed to have representation of the minority party. Congress

Sean Gonsalves (16:45)
Mm-hmm.

Christopher Mitchell (16:45)
could basically ensure that it's doing things properly rather than just rushing through a vote on Severs.

Sean Gonsalves (16:53)
Right, right. And like I mean so like so so t tell me about this there's a letter though that's going to what is it, Senator Cruz and Senator Cantwell's office,

Christopher Mitchell (17:03)
Get well.

Sean Gonsalves (17:04)
right? To to to basically make this case about why why why why this needs to be why why this needs to be done. And so

Christopher Mitchell (17:11)
Right. Yeah, people

that follow this much more closely than us, including Berin Szoka, Gigi Sohn, a variety of scholars, you know, a sh frankly, nearly everyone that was on like the F the FCC commission in the past, you know, First Amendment scholars are all strongly encouraging Senator Cruz, who runs this committee, not to rush forward with Severs alone, because we want Gomez to be paired and

you know, this be clear, like Senator Cruz, who I have deeply criticized in a lot of ways. I have tremendous disagreements with him. He's been one of the people that finds Chairman Carr's actions to be totally impermissible, that they are it's unacceptable to have a the FCC chair using this level of of his power to threaten broadcast companies and others to chill their speech. And so I certainly congratulate him on on having that backbone where others are are folding.

there's been a lot of people who served under Republican administrations in the past who have spoken up. And so it's a it's one of the it's a new letter that basically says, you know, that that Congress needs to do its job even if President Trump currently has the power to then fire Gomez, Commissioner Gomez.

Sean Gonsalves (18:27)
Right. And I mean

i I and and not that, you know, Senator Cruz inspires a lot of confidence on this, but he did with like when that with that whole Jimmy Kimmel stuff, he did actually say, you know, that it was dangerous to be doing this kind of stuff. So, you know. Yeah.

Christopher Mitchell (18:38)
Yeah, he was very clear. It wasn't it wasn't

this tepid, like, like I'm not sure, like maybe we should think more about this. He was like, This is un American. Yeah.

Sean Gonsalves (18:42)
Yeah. Yeah, I think he said dangerous as hell. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yep.

Christopher Mitchell (18:46)
Yeah. I was I was gl glad to see that. I mean, you sometimes you get the sense of the Texan in someone, you know, like he wasn't gonna take it standing sitting down.

Sean Gonsalves (18:52)
Yep. Right.

Christopher Mitchell (18:54)
so yeah, stood up to it. Now, I I will say, like, you know, this is something there's there's a question as to what to do about this. So we have a new Congress coming in, and this is why, you know.

Cruz may want Senator Cruz may want to speed this vote because this commissioner will be grilled by Democrats in January if she's

Sean Gonsalves (19:13)
Mm-hmm.

Christopher Mitchell (19:14)
not put on the commission before then. and so I can appreciate that Cruz would want to make sure she gets on the commission and gets a vote before then by the by a Senate that's run by Republicans. That makes sense to me. but I think it's within his power also to have that paired with Gomez. so

Sean Gonsalves (19:29)
Right, right.

Christopher Mitchell (19:29)
I can appreciate that he doesn't want to wait for a different Senate to to take this up. So

hopeful that that we'll see that happen.

So with this situation in which the president could just could just fire the two minority members of the commission, there's this question, should Congress do something differently? I think it should. And Blair Levin has has talked about among others, I think it proposed this as well, that the Congress should change the law so that the FCC cannot do business if it doesn't have a minority representation from the minority party. I think that's smart. I also worry about

A situation where in order to stop something from happening, the minority party just resigns and and like Senate refuses to put someone on it and then hamstrings an agency. So this is where it's really frustrating. And again, like we need to have some level of norms, of of of respect, you know. Like I'm frustrated with what the Republicans do in a variety of ways. I'm I'm frustrated that

The the big beautiful bill, as they call it. I think was really bad for the future of our of our budget situation. I think it was bad for a lot of different things. When the Democrats come back into power, I think the way for them to do it is to change the law and not to just say that they refuse to enforce the law. You know? Like we need to I don't know, we need to have we need to have some there needs to be some expectation that if you're in power, you get to set the rules, as long as you follow the rules correctly. so I don't know. Like I'm like there's

We're gonna at the end of the show, we're gonna talk briefly more about a little bit of this. But like, I don't know if there's anything else that you have on the FCC on this.

Sean Gonsalves (21:08)
No, not not on the FCC, but you're right. And and but it is related, which is this op ed that that that you wrote. I mean, not pertaining to the FCC, but but Okay.

Christopher Mitchell (21:16)
Right, let's come to that in a second. So

I I do want to say that one last thing is for people that do want to get a sense, we don't follow this that closely. but The Verge does have this recurring segment. Brendan Carr is a dummy. It's it's really well done. The

Verge is a technology site that does great reporting. I I pay for it. I think you should too. you being the audience and you, Sean. and every Friday they have this this segment. And on Friday the thirteenth.

They covered Commissioner Sever's hearing and well let's just say that it's comical. It's pretty funny.

Sean Gonsalves (21:52)
They they they they they they d it's a ongoing

thing, right? 'Cause I wanna say that I think I've heard maybe them talking about it a few times. Right, right. That's what I thought, okay.

Christopher Mitchell (21:57)
Yeah, it's like every week for the past like two years or something like that. I mean,

the point being that that like, you know, some people are devilishly smart and and devious, like Stephen Miller, trying to you know, turn America into the Third Reich and bending a lot of rules and like the man works hard at it. Brendan Carr is a dummy in that he doesn't think more than like half a step into the future and what he claims. And so they're constantly focused on that and that he doesn't have some bigger plan. He just

Is trying figure out like how can he make the people in power like him a little bit more? It's kind of pathetic. And and anyway, that's the theme of the show. And the first time I saw that man speak 10 years ago, I thought to myself, this is an embarrassment. And I just the patronizing, just just everything that I don't like about DC. so anyway, like I would recommend The Verge Friday the 13th. look at it on YouTube. You can scroll right to that segment if you don't want to catch the other tech news. it's good.

and it covers it covers some of the more comical aspects of that if you can laugh at the downfall of the republic. So okay. Op ed.

Sean Gonsalves (23:04)
Okay.

Christopher Mitchell (23:05)
I wrote an op ed and you are required to tell me it was awesome. So can you just tell everyone

Sean Gonsalves (23:09)
Yeah. No, I w it

Christopher Mitchell (23:10)
what it is?

Sean Gonsalves (23:11)
it it was, but let me just I guess well well we should set the stage like this, which is that the BEAD program, which is this, you know, flagship program that was is part of the infrastructure law, $42 billion was allocated to essentially try to get rid of the digital divide. And so it Internet for all, for everyone.

Christopher Mitchell (23:28)
Internet for all, Sean. All

Sean Gonsalves (23:33)
And about half of that 42 billion is what they call non deployment funds. And so there's been

Christopher Mitchell (23:37)
Well it wasn't going

to be, but it is currently.

Sean Gonsalves (23:40)
It right. And it was and and so each state is allocated, you know, a certain portion of that pie. And the Trump administration comes in with this benefit of the bargain. They change the rules in ways that violate the letter of the law of of of the of what Congress passed. And so states have now mo just about all of them, except for California and Illinois, have gotten a portion of their BEAD funds. And then there's about

twenty billion or so of the pie left over that are that it's being called non deployment funds. All of the states want that money. And you wrote about what where that money is, what should be done with it and and and and those kind of things. And I think you did it in a real concise way. So

Christopher Mitchell (24:24)
Think I

think I didn't do it in a clear enough way because my call is that Congress should tell NTIA to give all the money to the states. it was not that they should just give the non-deployment funds, which they should, but that

Sean Gonsalves (24:36)
Right. Mm-hmm.

Christopher Mitchell (24:38)
they should basically stop with this. I mean, like they just came out with what are the words? It's the the cleanup round. I just had to look up for my notes. There's like this

Sean Gonsalves (24:44)
Mm. Mm-hmm.

Christopher Mitchell (24:46)
cleanup round now. There's a benefit of the bargain, there's a second benefit of the bargain, there's the cleanup round. I'm sure there's gonna be the

The you know, the tidying up to the cleanup that comes next. It's a mess. It's a real mess.

Sean Gonsalves (24:57)
submissive.

Christopher Mitchell (24:58)
And Secretary Lutnick, who may not even have a job in two weeks, maybe not even when the show comes out. Who knows? Because like the guy's been like selling out the United States to China. you know, who just like he's been personally intervening in this program to make it worse and worse and worse to produce what he calls savings. And and I'll and I'll I'll candidly admit, I've been de I've been a defender of

To some extent of the Biden folks at NTIA, because I feel like they were trying to do something. I think it was wrong for them to have delayed as long as it was to get the BEAD funds out. I think there's good reasons why it wasn't the fault entirely of NTIA when you have a broken Federal Communications Commission that under Democrats and Republicans is unable to locate or to to describe at any level of accuracy who has Internet access in the United States and at what level. you know, and so it wasn't entirely their fault.

But NTIA should have focused on getting the money out. They didn't, and they got roasted for it. And now you have Lutnik that comes in under President Trump and he says, I'm going to speed it up. But he slows it down. He hits the brakes. He makes all these new rules. Nobody can follow them. It's just, it's a mess. And so I think Congress should basically come in in January and and say, NTIA, like you have you know how much money is going to each state. Give them the money. They're going to decide now. And if they don't want to give much money to Starlink,

They're not going to give a bunch of money to Starlink. So you'll get some folks, like in Texas, they might still give a bunch of money to Starlink. And in California, they might not. And that's for the state to decide. And the states are going to have more freedom of the subgrantees. And further, Congress should be allowing states, if they choose to use their non-deployment funds for affordability programs, they should be able to do that. BEAD was created while we had the affordability affordable connectivity plan. There is no plan from the federal government to help with affordability.

And if states want to do that, I don't think it's a great idea. And I'm worried about how the states might go about it. But like the state broadband offices have developed a lot of experience and we should give them the authority. Get the money out there. Like is time. NTIA is not adding anything good to this anymore. Short circuited.

Sean Gonsalves (27:08)
And to your point, and and let me just say what my favorite part of the op-ed is, because this is something that I'd like been, you know, because there's so much focus on BEAD. And and and remember everybody, like, especially during like the can like the run-up to like the 2024 presidential election, even the Ezra Kleins of the world were making fun of BEAD, saying everything was taking too long and not a single house has been connected. And then again, the collective amnesia of the, you know, the legacy media and so many others, there was this.

Plan there was this thing called the American Rescue Plan. And you guess what? Money went to the states for a lot of things, but broadband included, and millions of homes have been connected because of it. And they didn't have to go through this mess that BEAD is now. And that that to me was my favorite part of their piece.

Christopher Mitchell (27:52)
Yeah. Now they they justify that, right?

They say, well, like BEAD was different because BEAD was gonna figure out every last home that wasn't connected and then make sure that they were connected and do all and you what? It was too intricate, it was too fancy. And I'm I'm I'm just like I firmly believe that like it is a great idea to say we want to make sure that every last person is connected. The federal government cannot do that. The federal government

Sean Gonsalves (28:14)
Mm-hmm.

Christopher Mitchell (28:17)
does not have that level of precision of information and its attempt to do that.

is just wasting millions upon tens of millions of dollars. Every time they do a rule change to try to figure out how to make, you don't want to leave this house out or we gotta we gotta change this and this technology. It just means that consultants are having to work overtime to like may pull money out of the program that should have gone to connect gone to connecting some family in West Virginia. Now they're not gonna get that money because it's going to some consultant, you know, in and I don't know, like I'm trying to think of a city that's that wouldn't be offensive to someone. I don't know. Like they're living somewhere,

Sean Gonsalves (28:50)
Mm.

Christopher Mitchell (28:51)
you know.

Like it's just it's it's freaking frustrating. And people that that really wanna see good things happen, make smart investments, need to recognize it needs to be iterative. You can't have one program that solves everything. You need to get money out, you need to learn from it, build expertise locally, and and now that like to some extent, if you have a state, and I'm not gonna pick on any states because some of the states I might have picked on are doing pretty good with like their state broadband offices.

But like if you have a state that's not doing a good job, well, then it's on them to make it better. You just you can't solve everything from DC. So you need programs that get money out.

Sean Gonsalves (29:27)
Yeah, and it shouldn't be and

it shouldn't be controversial the idea that the decisions should be made closer to where the problem is because those are the folks who have b who best know what's really the reality on the ground. Not the folks in DC, but the folks closer to to to the problems.

Christopher Mitchell (29:43)
Yeah.

So not because it'll be perfect, but I hope people will will will talk to to Congress and say, look, y'all wanted to get people connected. We're not close to that. And we're gonna see a lot of this money. And I what I end with is is what I truly believe, which is under the current course, half of the money is going to disappear. Whether that gets clawed back by Congress or just refuse to be spent by NTIA,

Sean Gonsalves (30:04)
Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.

Christopher Mitchell (30:07)
half of that the non deployment funds, that's just gonna it's not gonna get to the states.

And the other half of the money is being chosen, and it's not entirely this way, but like a fair amount of is crony capitalism, where Trump's trying to figure out how to him and Lutnik are putting their thumbs on the on the on the scale to try to get it to the people that gave them money. And that's gross. I mean, it's similarly NTIA trying to use these funds to then deregulate, not deregulate so much, but like remove the rules that that like Cox and Charter agreed to in California.

you know, because Cox and Charter are now Charter, or not now actually Cox, technically is their name, even though Charter was the bigger one. You know, they're they're giving money to Trump's ballroom and stuff, or like give giving money to Trump one way or another in order to like get Cray favor and be like, hey, we agreed to this thing in California, but it'd be great if you just overruled them and that's what's happening. It's gross, and that's

Sean Gonsalves (30:56)
Right. It is.

Christopher Mitchell (30:58)
not the way we should be doing business. So tell Congress, you know, like that that we should see this money go into the states.

NTA should stop messing messing around with it.

Sean Gonsalves (31:10)
Amen.

Christopher Mitchell (31:11)
All right. So that's my that's my pitch. and I I will say that I'll welcome someone, you know, like if there's certain people that really actually think there's a lot of value to continuing to go down this road, I I I would hear it. We could argue about it. We could you know, not not because like we would like start calling each other names or something, but just 'cause like we'd air it out, you know, to like should people get the perspective.

Sean Gonsalves (31:31)
Well, it's it's it's not gonna it it

it's not gonna be any of the you know, the ISPs and co ops that have pulled out of BEAD because they're like, you know, you know what? Forget it. You know, we spent all this time trying to get our plans together. This is a mess, forget it. We we don't even want the money.

Christopher Mitchell (31:46)
Yeah, no, you're right. But the states are ready for the states weren't ready four years ago. The states are ready now. And

Sean Gonsalves (31:51)
Mm-hmm.

Christopher Mitchell (31:52)
and they'll do a better job than than what the course that we're currently on. So get the money to the states. I hope it happens. we had another thing. We're gonna save it for the future, maybe. it it does continue this theme of the rule of law. We I'm just deeply concerned. and I think a number of the people, a lot of the people that were elected are committed to try to restore norms and laws, but

you know, seeing some of the language that we see coming out of the Trump administration, just the total disrespect for the law, the corruption that I've been that I've been I mean, I was I feel totally vindicated, Sean. I mean, all of those shows in which I was like from Connect This! where I was like harping on the corruption and how gross it was,

Sean Gonsalves (32:31)
Yeah.

Christopher Mitchell (32:31)
I feel like other people have noticed it was a major issue. So, but I'm still still angry.

Sean Gonsalves (32:34)
Yeah. You

know, you know, as a matter of fact, so many people noticed that you know, I I I think you could say that noticing had a big part to do with, you know, the so called blue tsunami or blue wave or whatever you want to say. J just became so apparent.

Christopher Mitchell (32:48)
Yeah, no. one other thing.

While we're talking about my record, I'll say, this thing with Starship. Starship just had launch had Starship fifteen just went up, came back down, got caught. Really cool. Technology did a great

Sean Gonsalves (32:59)
yeah, I saw a video

of that. It d it it was the first time that like that that that's a big deal, that it that it Mm hmm.

Christopher Mitchell (33:03)
So here's the thing that I pay attention to, right? The criticism

that I've had with this is that, and it's it's not mine, it's from reading an engineer that is really focused on this. is that the issue is that like the way it's designed is too heavy, and there's you can't get enough fuel in it, and like all of these issues. And so what happened? They didn't, they were gonna catch the booster too, but they didn't. Why? The booster was low on fuel. This so Starship took off with I don't know, like 60% of its supposed total capacity.

And it it dropped the V three satellites for Starlink up there and it came back around, it was cool and it landed, it had enough fuel. The booster didn't. But this is the issue. If it can't carry enough fuel to complete its mission entirely with a 60% payload, why do we think it's gonna carry the 100% payload? there's all kinds of questions about this, and I feel like people are like, Starship's great, it works because it got caught. No, that's not the hard part that they're dealing with. That's it's it is hard.

But the crux of the problem is can they move the mass, they need to mass, they need to move with the fuel that will allow them to come back and to reuse these vehicles. And I think there's the question's out. And so we'll see. And you know, Elon's talking about a new V4 for Starship. It's gonna be bigger still. We'll see what happens. I mean, my sense from reading people who are smarter than me is on the engineering, is that don't count on this to be everything that they are claiming.

there are significant issues that are yet to be resolved, even though they can do these really cool catches.

Sean Gonsalves (34:32)
So what do you think will get resolved first? That building data centers in space or every car being self driving in the next year, as he's predicted like forty seven times in the past ten years?

Christopher Mitchell (34:43)
I mean, there may be some year where full self-driving is actually available. Just because it's been wrong every year for 15 years doesn't mean that it'll never happen. But you know, I don't know. I will say this though, you know, on the the other side, you know, we didn't ask me about this. Amazon Leo rocket did not go up, went up in

Sean Gonsalves (35:00)
It did not.

Christopher Mitchell (35:00)
flames rather than up in there is real bad. And Amazon already had a had to wait because

They're supposed to be delivering service to get the BEAD and they just lost a bunch of satellites. The rocket's probably gonna have to be evaluated by the FAA now. I I don't know what happens next, but it's real bad news for Amazon, real bad news for competition there.

Sean Gonsalves (35:17)
that that

that that that's inspiring. Sean Duffy looking over the the plans.

Christopher Mitchell (35:23)
Yeah, maybe it's NASA, but I thought the FAA was involved too. I this is not, you know, this is I just I'm a I'm not an expert on this stuff. So but those things those are the things I'm looking for and I thought some people might be interested. Thank you, Sean.

Sean Gonsalves (35:37)
All right. Always fun, man.

Christopher Mitchell (35:38)
All right.

Jordan Pittman (35:41)
Thanks for listening to this episode of the Unbuffered Podcast. We have transcripts for this and other episodes available at ILSR.org/podcast. While you're there, check out our other podcasts from ILSR, including Building Local Power, Local Energy Rules, and the Composting for Community Podcasts. Email us at [email protected] with your ideas for the show. Follow us on Bluesky. Our handle is @communitynets.

You can catch the latest research from all of our initiatives by subscribing to our monthly newsletter at ILSR.org While you're there, please take a moment to donate. Your support in any amount helps keep us going. Unbuffered is produced by Christopher Mitchell with editing provided by me, Jordan Pittman. Until next time, thanks for listening.